Blog · Production

Proof approval for custom orders: how it cuts disputes and refunds

PUBLISHED: · UPDATED · 5 MIN READ

"That's not what I ordered." With a normal product, you check the order and ship a replacement. With a personalized one, you look at the design the customer submitted, see that it matches the print exactly, and still lose: the name was spelled wrong in the order, the photo was the wrong one, the colour looked different on their phone. There is no replacement in stock, and the item cannot be resold.

A proof is a simple fix. Before anything is printed, the customer sees the final artwork and says yes. If they later say it is wrong, you have their approval on record. More often, they spot the typo while it still costs nothing to fix.

When a proof is worth it

Not every order needs one. A proof adds a step, and every step slows some customers down. Require it where a mistake is expensive:

Require a proofUsually skip it
Large or bulk ordersSingle low-cost items
Expensive blanks (hoodies, jackets, framed prints)Simple text on a mug
Business orders with logosDesigns made entirely in the designer with fixed templates
Anything your staff adjust before printingOrders you print within the hour

The last row matters. If staff move a logo or fix a colour before printing, the customer never saw that version. A proof closes that gap.

What a good proof flow looks like

  1. The order is paid and waits. It gets a clear status, such as "Awaiting approval", so nobody prints it by accident.
  2. Staff send a proof of each personalized line: the artwork as it will print.
  3. The customer approves or asks for changes from their account, without having to email.
  4. A change request starts a new version. The old one is kept, marked as replaced.
  5. Only approved artwork goes to production.
  6. Everything is logged: who sent what, when, and what the customer answered.

Setting it up with Proof & Approval

The Proof & Approval addon follows that flow on WooCommerce, OpenCart, PrestaShop and Shopware.

  • One proof per personalized line, with versions. Each version has a status: draft, sent, approved, changes requested, superseded or cancelled.
  • An "Awaiting approval" order status, so the order is visibly on hold.
  • Customers answer from My Account. Guests answer from their order page. Approving requires ticking a confirmation box; requesting changes requires a comment, and the customer can attach a reference image of up to 5 MB.
  • Emails, reminders and an auto-approval timer. Customers are told when a proof is ready and reminded if they do not answer. If you set a timer, a proof nobody answers is approved after that time, so orders do not wait for ever.
  • An audit trail of every proof, answer and status change on the order.

Settings are in Production → Proofs. Set a global default, then override it per product: require proofs on hoodies, skip them on mugs.

Decide on auto-approval before you switch it on. It keeps orders moving, but it means some customers never actively say yes. Say so on the product page or in the proof email, so "approved" means the same thing to them as it does to you.

Connecting it to production

If you also use Print Queue, only approved lines are sent to production. A line with changes requested stays out of the queue until the new version is approved, so a station cannot print an old version by mistake.

Write proof messages people understand

The proof email is the moment the customer pays attention. Keep it short and specific:

Please check your design before we print it. Check the spelling, the photo and the position. Once you approve, we print exactly this artwork. Need a change? Click "Request changes" and tell us what to fix.

The words "we print exactly this" do most of the work. They tell the customer what their approval means.

What changes in your numbers

Proofs move effort from after-sales to before production. You will spend a little more time sending proofs, and much less time on complaints, reprints and refunds that start with "this isn't what I wanted". For the orders where you require them, a signed-off proof also answers most disputes on its own.

FAQ

Does the customer need an account?

No. Customers with an account answer from My Account; guests answer from their order page.

Can I require proofs only for some products?

Yes. Set the global default, then override it per product.

What happens to the original design when a change is requested?

It is kept. The new version supersedes it, and the history shows both.

Next steps

Read the Proof & Approval docs, then decide which of your products should require a proof. Start with the most expensive one.

Read the docs See all addons

← All posts